I’ve only had two sessions with working on Dudley’s tugging through click-and-treat, and we’ve gotten further in those two sessions than all the frustrating sessions I had in the last two weeks with Dudley and the Tug It.  All he wanted to do is lick that.  Once upon a time, he did grip it.  And occasionally, he would grab it when in the mood during our training out in the back yard.  But now he is grabbing the tug.  Step by step, we will lengthen the process and I hope to have him tugging soon!